Right path for roaming?

Plans to reduce roaming rates are laudable, but regulators must exercise caution
Roger Field is editor of CommsMEA.
Roger Field is editor of CommsMEA.


With operators making solid progress to improve roaming services in the MENA region, the GSMA warns regulators against taking a similar approach to Europe and imposing a one-size-fits-all set of regulations on operators.

The GCC issued a statement in January calling on Gulf telecoms operatorsto slash mobile phone roaming charges to consumers by at least 50% from Feb 1. At first sight, the statement, which was made by Abdullah al-Shibli, GCC assistant secretary general for economic affairs, appeared to make sense – particularly from the point of view of consumers. Roaming rates in the Gulf are significantly higher than other regions, including Europe.

But what enthusiasts of such regulation often forget is the reasoning behind the roaming tariffs as they are. Operators in the region have invested heavily in their networks in recent years and in most Gulf countries, competition has also been encouraged. Roaming revenues account for a significant proportion of overall revenues for many telcos, and a sudden forced reduction in tariffs at this stage may well simply lead to price rises in others, or less investment in other areas.

Of course, this is not to say that the GCC’s aim to see roaming tariffs in the Gulf fall in line with those in other countries and regions is inherently wrong. It is just that regulation can sometimes have unintended consequences. And on top of this, there is much evidence that Gulf operators are already moving in the right direction.

As Peter Lyons, director of spectrum policy, Africa & Middle East at the GSM Association, stated at last month’s Roaming MENA Conference in Dubai, the region’s operators are making progress. Indeed, the cost of outgoing roaming calls from UAE to Egypt from 2007 to 2011 fell by 48%, while the same service from KSA to Kuwait decreased by 82% in the same timeframe.

“Operators are responding to competition in the market and are driving prices down across the region,” he said.

Moreover, operators have also been making solid e_orts to increase transparency of roaming rates. Operators including Du and Etisalat simplified their roaming tariffs in 2009 and 2010 respectively. International outbound roamers with Etisalat are charged one of three rates according to their location, while Du launched its “One World, One Rate” to remove any confusion from the cost of roaming for its subscribers.

While market forces and competition appear to be pushing operators in the right direction with respect to roaming, any unduly heavy-handed regulation could potentially cause more harm than good. One of the main challenges with drafting any pan-GCC regulation is that each of the countries has different economies, with their own inflation rates and GDPs, so a one-size- fits all approach can be more of a burden for some operators than others. It can also lead to what Lyon’s refers to as the “waterbed” effect, where pushing down prices in one area will simply lead to a rise in another.

“Introducing regulation at this point could distort the market and we really think it’s best to leave a good thing alone. If it’s not broken, don’t try to fix it,” Lyons said. But not everybody agreed with the view that regulators should keep out of roaming. One speaker at the roaming event pointed out that regulation is also sometimes needed to protect against distortions in the market that can be created by dominant players. He cited the example of Zain Group, which launched its “One Network” initiative, which offered roaming at local rates across many of its operations, as an example. He questioned how other smaller operators would have been able to compete with this type of initiative.

But most speakers at the event seemed to tow the operator line that regulation at this stage is more likely to slow down, rather than speed up, a fall in roaming rates. Lyons also revealed that Europe offers an example of how regulation can sometimes have the opposite effect from what was intended by its architects. When roaming regulations were first implemented in Europe in 2007, the cost of roaming was already falling rapidly. This rate slowed following the regulation. Regulators may be well advised to study the lessons from Europe before following a similar path in the Gulf.

Editor's Choice

Deception technologies, AI and Robo Hunters to  displace legacy cybersecurity solutions
IoT is rapidly expanding the attack surface of the digital enterprise and exposing it to enhanced risk levels not seen before. Deception technologies, artificial intelligence, Robo-hunters, are solutions for tomorrow's enterprise, Mechelle Buys Du Plessis, MD – UAE, Dimension Data.
The robots are coming: Impact of AI on executive search
As the technology industry’s elite struggle to agree on the potential impact of AI and a raft of people queuing up to advise on the potential disruption it will cause, this article by John Curtis-Oliver, Partner at Boyden studies the potential impact on the executive hiring and the executive search industry.
#MWC2018: Spotlight shines on 5G, IoT and AR
Hard to predict what will ‘turn around the fate’ of telecom operators, but there is potential for those who can play the role of enabling platform for new digital services and players, as well as for new features and capabilities across traditional industries, says Luis Cirne, partner, communications, media and technology (CMT) practice at Oliver Wyman

Most popular

Don't Miss a Story

You may also like

Can AI give wings to the MVNO business model?
In the MVNO business, an ordinary performance is not enough to succeed. It requires speed, lean operation and efficient monetisation capabilities.
Internet of Broken Things? 10 key facts about IoT
It’s crazy to think that devices with the potential to enable so much damage to homes, businesses and even entire cities often lack basic security design, implementation and testing.
The Why, the What and the How of a digital transformation
For business-driven organisations, expected revenue-generation/benefits supported by a bold vision of the digital services/roadmap, help a lot in re-adapting mentalities of the decision-makers in place, stabilising the focus, and optimising the magnitude of the innovation.
Availability: Why it must be a vital tool for cloud service providers in the Middle East
As it becomes more important to differentiate in the cloud provision market, one of the primary areas a CSP can sell itself is in making assurances about service availability, data protection and backup. In other words, removing the risk of things that let customers down and make the news in the process (as much as possible).